2024-25 NFL Thread

[jesmu84]

Maybe he meant someone would be willing to take him off their hands for a #8 overall if the Bears threw in the #1 pick overall as compensation for taking him.

That's about as realistic.

Except that he said if Bears traded away fields for #8, they would then have 1, 8, 9

[GB Warrior]

No one's trading a first for Fields. Spending a first on a running back just isn't a smart investment

[Lennys Tap]

No one's trading a first for Fields. Spending a first on a running back just isn't a smart investment

Ironically that's exactly what Atlanta did last year.

[GB Warrior]

Bears interviewing Greg Roman as OC candidate is a potential tell. Get your pitchforks ready, Bears fans!

[Pakuni]

@AtlantaFalcons
We have interviewed Bill Belichick for our head coach opening

[MU82]

The Athletic has J.J. McCarthy going #19 to the Rams.

Williams #1 to Chicago, Maye #2 to Washington and Daniels #8 to Atlanta.

FWIW (not much).

[WhiteTrash]

The Athletic has J.J. McCarthy going #19 to the Rams.

Williams #1 to Chicago, Maye #2 to Washington and Daniels #8 to Atlanta.

FWIW (not much).

Feels a bit "chalky". No big diversions from all other predictions other than McCarthy somewhat higher than most.

I do think Chicago will go with Williams unless they get offered "stupid" compensation. (3 #1s & 3 #2's type 'never going to happen' stupid)

Agree these are not worth more than bracketology in December. Combine, workouts, FA and trades will cause major changes.

[Jockey]

The Athletic has J.J. McCarthy going #19 to the Rams.

Williams #1 to Chicago, Maye #2 to Washington and Daniels #8 to Atlanta.

FWIW (not much).

So many QB needy teams. I think a team will see JJ as the next Josh Allen and he goes top 10. QBs always get overdrafted.

[Uncle Rico]

So many QB needy teams. I think a team will see JJ as the next Josh Allen and he goes top 10. QBs always get overdrafted.

Tommy DeVito started games in the NFL this year.  Mason Rudolph started a playoff game.  The NFL is desperate for QBs.

Thank god for Jordan Love

[JWags85]

So many QB needy teams. I think a team will see JJ as the next Josh Allen and he goes top 10. QBs always get overdrafted.

Josh Allen?  Cause he has a big arm?  Otherwise I don't see the comp at all.  Allen is bigger, more of a running threat, and was really raw coming out of a mid major college.  McCarthy isn't as mobile, more polished, and not at all under the radar.

But otherwise I totally agree with your final point.  Especially in years where there is tons of good QBs prospects at the top, FOMO comes in hard.

[Uncle Rico]

Josh Allen?  Cause he has a big arm?  Otherwise I don't see the comp at all.  Allen is bigger, more of a running threat, and was really raw coming out of a mid major college.  McCarthy isn't as mobile, more polished, and not at all under the radar.

But otherwise I totally agree with your final point.  Especially in years where there is tons of good QBs prospects at the top, FOMO comes in hard.

McCarthy is quite mobile.  Michigan didn't use him much in the running game.  When they did, he moved the chains

[MU82]

@AtlantaFalcons
We have interviewed Bill Belichick for our head coach opening

Sources say, here's a transcript from the interview.

Q: Why don't you tell us about yourself?

A: I coach.

Q; What interests you about this position?

A: Football.

Q: Where do you see yourself in 10 years?

A: Breathing.

[JWags85]

Sources say, here's a transcript from the interview.

Q: Why don't you tell us about yourself?

A: I coach.

Q; What interests you about this position?

A: Football.

Q: Where do you see yourself in 10 years?

A: Breathing.

O/U on the number of questions before Bill said "we done here?"....6?

[Pakuni]

Josh Allen?  Cause he has a big arm?  Otherwise I don't see the comp at all.  Allen is bigger, more of a running threat, and was really raw coming out of a mid major college.  McCarthy isn't as mobile, more polished, and not at all under the radar.

But otherwise I totally agree with your final point.  Especially in years where there is tons of good QBs prospects at the top, FOMO comes in hard.

I think McCarthy as a smaller Allen isn't the worst comp Ive ever seen, but maybe not the best. He doesn't have Allen's arm or size, but he's as mobile and more accurate. McCarthy reminds me more of .poor man's Andrew Luck. Maybe very poor man's. Smaller and not the elite arm talent, but tough, accurate and smart, and similar playing styles.

[Pakuni]

O/U on the number of questions before Bill said "we done here?"....6?

How did the interview go?
"I'm on to Dallas."
But what were your impressions of the Falcons?
"I'm on to Dallas."

[The Hippie Satan of Hyperbole]

This is really the issue with teams looking at Belichick right? They want Bill the Coach, but not really Bill the GM. And Bill likely wants both right?

I thought for sure that he would be heading to the Cowboys, but Shannon Sharpe's diatribe about why that would be a disaster got me thinking - would he put up with Jones doing Jones things? (Trading for Trey Lance without talking to the coach, going on the radio weekly, etc.) Or do desperate parties come together for a deal thinking it would work, only to have it fall apart spectacularly?

[Jockey]

How did the interview go?
"I'm on to Dallas."
But what were your impressions of the Falcons?
"I'm on to Dallas."

I'm probably wrong, but I just don't see the Belichick to Cowboys thing.

Is Bill going to want to go to a place where the owner has final say on everything? There is a reason why the Cowboys are losers. Jerry's ego must always be satisfied and he will always sacrifice the team at the altar of ego and money.

[Pakuni]

I'm probably wrong, but I just don't see the Belichick to Cowboys thing.

Is Bill going to want to go to a place where the owner has final say on everything? There is a reason why the Cowboys are losers. Jerry's ego must always be satisfied and he will always sacrifice the team at the altar of ego and money.

You may be right. Definitely a fair point.
On the other hand, does soon-to-be 72-year-old Belichick want to go to a rebuild, or a team that's years from being a legitimate contender, i.e. the Falcons, Washington or Carolina?
The downside of the Cowboys is dealing with Jerry. But the upside is he takes over a roster that can compete for a Super Bowl immediately.

[GB Warrior]

Belichick could do wonders with that defense but i have a feeling he's not going to be into the brand of football that Diggs and Bland play. Ultimate gamblers.

[forgetful]

How did the interview go?
"I'm on to Dallas."
But what were your impressions of the Falcons?
"I'm on to Dallas."

So far there has been Belichick to the Cowboys, Packers (before they won), Philly, Chargers, and Atlanta.

With the flame outs of the Cowboys and Philly, I wouldn't be shocked to see him end up at either of those places. Right now, Bill just wants 2 seasons where he can win a total of at least 15 games. If Philly and/or the Cowboys offer, he goes there. I don't think he cares as much about controlling everything as he does getting the all time Wins record.

[JWags85]

You may be right. Definitely a fair point.
On the other hand, does soon-to-be 72-year-old Belichick want to go to a rebuild, or a team that's years from being a legitimate contender, i.e. the Falcons, Washington or Carolina?
The downside of the Cowboys is dealing with Jerry. But the upside is he takes over a roster that can compete for a Super Bowl immediately.

Shades of Parcells tenure in Dallas?  Legendary SB winning coach and ego having one last hurrah with Jerry before retirement?

[Herman Cain]

https://www.foxnews.com/sports/bill-belichick-knows-exactly-what-he-wants-next-coaching-gig-report

[Uncle Rico]

Sounds like Jim Irsay's respiratory illness is code for overdose

[Lennys Tap]

McCarthy is quite mobile.  Michigan didn't use him much in the running game.  When they did, he moved the chains

He's also only 20 years old. His best situation would be to sit for a couple of years and learn from a good coach and QB. The Rams maybe?

[Uncle Rico]

He's also only 20 years old. His best situation would be to sit for a couple of years and learn from a good coach and QB. The Rams maybe?

I think that's a good call.  A team like that would benefit him.