Adios AA

[4everwarriors]

Admission to college to be based on merit and not just checking the right boxes, hey?

[wadesworld]

Admission to college to be based on merit and not just checking the right boxes, hey?

Absolutely.  Just ask all those legacy kids...

[lawdog77]

Admission to college to be based on merit and not just checking the right boxes, hey?

Too bad we haven't fixed the need for it, yet.

[TSmith34, Inc.]

Merit like Jarod Kushner and George Bush?

[Pakuni]

They ended legacy admissions?

[wadesworld]

My unborn child could be a D1 rower for the right price...

[MU82]

Thank goodness! College is safe again!

IBTL

[4everwarriors]

AA really did a disservice to those admitted. For example, in my daughter's high school class was an African American student who matriculated to Harvard. He was arguably one of the brightest students I've run across... AP Scholar, National Merit Finalist. Unfortunately, he'll likely go through life with people saying he got in to Harvard based on AA. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He earned it.
The current Press Secretary, on the other hand, is an entirely different story, hey?

[Spotcheck Billy]

AA really did a disservice to those admitted. For example, in my daughter's high school school was an African American student who matriculated to Harvard. He was arguably one of the brightest students I've run across... AP Scholar, National Merit Finalist. Unfortunately, he'll likely go through life with people saying he got in to Harvard based on AA. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He earned it.

Why do you make that assumption?
Maybe only dentists think like that.

[lawdog77]

AA really did a disservice to those admitted. For example, in my daughter's high school school was an African American student who matriculated to Harvard. He was arguably one of the brightest students I've run across... AP Scholar, National Merit Finalist. Unfortunately, he'll likely go through life with people saying he got in to Harvard based on AA. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He earned it.
The current Press Secretary, on the other hand, is an entirely different story, hey?

If that's the biggest problem of AA, that is a successful program

[Uncle Rico]

Why do you make that assumption?
Maybe only dentists think like that.

Shut up and drill

[MU82]

And all this time, I thought Alcoholics Anonymous helped people. Can't believe we have to say adios to AA.

[Pakuni]

Unfortunately, he'll likely go through life with people racists saying he got in to Harvard based on AA. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He earned it.

FTFY.

[Uncle Rico]

And all this time, I thought Alcoholics Anonymous helped people. Can't believe we have to say adios to AA.

AA is another example of America being fool in’ soft, aina?

[Dickthedribbler]

Merit like Jarod Kushner and George Bush?

And Malia Obama?

[Dr. Blackheart]

This ruling will be controversial but the reality is it the demographics of college have changed and will continue to change.  Females are now the vast majority of college students and whites will soon be under 50%. What's interesting is that it is the Asians who filed these lawsuits as they were stuck in a quota system.  The reality is AA and Title IX have become in parts largely obsolete over time as to what was intended (mostly by demographics naturally).

These laws shouldn't be evergreened but should be updated to reflect 2023 not 1973. The reality is, these were very successful in accomplishing their intent.

[TSmith34, Inc.]

And Malia Obama?

Maybe, though I admit I am completely ignorant WRT Malia's academics or ability to get into Harvard if she weren't the daughter of a former President.

I am quite positive OTOH that Jarod and Shrub would have had difficulty getting into Western Illinois without their connections.

[wadesworld]

I can honestly say I never once thought that someone only got into the college they did because they were African American or a minority.

[Coleman]

I don't agree with the ruling but I don't think it will have that big of an impact. Schools will find other ways to get diverse student bodies, it just officially and explicitly can't be based on race.

You can use socio-economic status, family background, upbringing, etc.

A lot of room to get this type of information in certain essay questions without ever explicitly bringing up race.

[Warriors4ever]

I can only hope that is true, Coleman.
These justices that decided this, and their cheerleaders, are living in a bubble of their own making.

[Uncle Rico]

I don't agree with the ruling but I don't think it will have that big of an impact. Schools will find other ways to get diverse student bodies, it just officially and explicitly can't be based on race.

You can use socio-economic status, family background, upbringing, etc.

A lot of room to get this type of information in certain essay questions without ever explicitly bringing up race.

Strongly disagree.  One political party is doing everything they can to destroy the American educational system.  They’ve spent decades attacking teachers and the educated people of this country. 

[shoothoops]

AA really did a disservice to those admitted. For example, in my daughter's high school class was an African American student who matriculated to Harvard. He was arguably one of the brightest students I've run across... AP Scholar, National Merit Finalist. Unfortunately, he'll likely go through life with people saying he got in to Harvard based on AA. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He earned it.
The current Press Secretary, on the other hand, is an entirely different story, hey?

Insecure racist White Man who cannot speak one language, jealously lashes out at Black Woman who speaks several languages.



 

[MUBurrow]

If that's the biggest problem of AA, that is a successful program

This is 100% it for me right here.

[The Hippie Satan of Hyperbole]

I don't agree with the ruling but I don't think it will have that big of an impact. Schools will find other ways to get diverse student bodies, it just officially and explicitly can't be based on race.

You can use socio-economic status, family background, upbringing, etc.

A lot of room to get this type of information in certain essay questions without ever explicitly bringing up race.

Yep. Many colleges and universities stopped explicitly using race a long time ago in anticipation of a ruling like this. IMO it will result in very little change to what many places are already doing.

[Jockey]

They ended legacy admissions?

GWB. Is smiling today. Mediocre, rich white kids have been sparred.