I'll admit I'm biased but.......

[tower912]

It ain't grilled cheese without crunchy peanut butter dripping out of it.

[The Lens]

American cheese is an abomination.

Thank you 🫡

[Farley36]

Not in a grilled cheese or on a burger.  If you say otherwise you're just wrong and a cheese snob.   Nothing else melts the same.

[MU82]

I'll happily admit I'm a cheese snob if it means I get to eat cheddar, Swiss, pepperjack, goat cheese, smoked gouda, havarti, etc, rather than American cheese.

Just as I'll happily admit I'm a beer snob if it means I never have to drink another PBR for the rest of my life.

If y'all want to eat and drink inferior crud, though, that's cool.

[MuggsyB]

Don't forget JTY's triple on Monday.  One of the biggest reg season shots in a long time. 

[wadesworld]

Not in a grilled cheese or on a burger.  If you say otherwise you're just wrong and a cheese snob.   Nothing else melts the same.

I agree with this.  Of course if you're making just a list of cheeses overall, American is way down that list.  But on a burger or grilled cheese, it's way up towards the top.

[MuggsyB]

I agree with this.  Of course if you're making just a list of cheeses overall, American is way down that list.  But on a burger or grilled cheese, it's way up towards the top.

The chef from The Menu said American Cheese is the best for a burger.  But he's no longer with us. 

[Farley36]

I agree with this.  Of course if you're making just a list of cheeses overall, American is way down that list.  But on a burger or grilled cheese, it's way up towards the top.

This is the correct answer.  I'm not throwing American cheese on a charcuterie board.  The conversation here isn't about best cheeses you'd want to eat.  It's about the best cheese for a grilled cheese. 

[Pakuni]

American cheese is an abomination.

Keep your anti-American screeds to the Superbar, Sultan.

[FairWeatherEagle]

It ain't grilled cheese without crunchy peanut butter dripping out of it.

"Pizza! now that's a Taco!"   

[MU82]

Bill Self will fight - or at least make like he's gonna fight as he says, "Hold me back!" - anybody who claims that American cheese isn't the best cheese on a burger.

[warriorchick]

I can't imagine why anyone who has ever lived in Wisconsin would eat American cheese.

Kraft singles should be like artificially-colored margarine in the old days - banned in the state.

[Spaniel with a Short Tail]

American cheese is an abomination.

[warriorchick]

It ain't grilled cheese without crunchy peanut butter dripping out of it.

Speaking as someone who absolutely loves both grilled cheese sandwiches and peanut butter: