2015 - Who's Better? Hill or Matthews?

[esotericmindguy]

I'll say Hill with a season under his belt. I'm not a recruiting junkie, but it seems like these two are very similar players. 6'5 around 180-190 SGs. Obviously it can't hurt to have more highly touted players, but with JJJ, Duane and Cohen as sophomores how many 6'5 guard/wings can play? Sounds like Hill is an underrated recruit that could be in the top 25 with a better summer.

[GGGG]

Matthews.  Plays in a much more competitive high school environment and starred for a top level AAU team.

[tower912]

I don't know.   Nobody does.   But the presence of JJJ, Hill, Cohen, Duane keeps me from getting too despondent about young Mr. Matthews' choice.  

[TAMU, Knower of Ball]

I'm optimistic about Hill but Matthews is a consensus top 12 prospect.

[esotericmindguy]

I'm optimistic about Hill but Matthews is a consensus top 12 prospect.

Well, he was a top 25 prospect until this past summer. Apparently he was forced to play PG. Plus he'll be a sophomore.

[Jay Bee]

I'll say Hill with a season under his belt. I'm not a recruiting junkie, but it seems like these two are very similar players. 6'5 around 180-190 SGs. Obviously it can't hurt to have more highly touted players, but with JJJ, Duane and Cohen as sophomores how many 6'5 guard/wings can play? Sounds like Hill is an underrated recruit that could be in the top 25 with a better summer.

Different players. Matthews has a very high ceiling.

[downtown85]

Wes is better.  He plays in the league. 

[TAMU, Knower of Ball]

Wes is better.  He plays in the league. 

Just making sure you know we are talking about Charles Matthews...not Wes

[bilsu]

Matthews was recruited by Kentucky and as far as I know they had no interest in Hill.