Theoretical

[KenoshaWarrior]

Which scenario would you chose.

1.Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill tell Marquette, that if they hire Brian Wardle they will commit.   

2. Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill say that they will not play for Shaka Smart, and instead will head to the Badgers

3. Ahmad Hill says that if you Hire Ben Howland, I am in.  D-Stone says I will play for Badgers if you hire him.   


I pick scenario 1

[PuertoRicanNightmare]

You're telling me you're letting 17 year olds decide who's going to coach us?

[ChicosBailBonds]

Letting players run the asylum.  No thanks, especially a high school junior who will only play at his college a max of two years.  Short term thinking in my view.

[Coleman]

This is the dumbest thread I've read today, which is saying a lot

[NersEllenson]

This is the dumbest thread I've read today, which is saying a lot

+1

[NavinRJohnson]

Which scenario would you chose.

1.Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill tell Marquette, that if they hire Brian Wardle they will commit.   

2. Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill say that they will not play for Shaka Smart, and instead will head to the Badgers

3. Ahmad Hill says that if you Hire Ben Howland, I am in.  D-Stone says I will play for Badgers if you hire him.   


I pick scenario 1

4. You don't ask any recruits their opinions, and hire the guy you think is the best for the job.

[mileskishnish72]

True, Bleu.

[chapman]

4. You don't ask any recruits their opinions, and hire the guy you think is the best for the job.

This one.  Scoop fans (assuming most are alumni and boosters) should have more input in the coaching search than recruits, especially unsigned ones.  And that is next to none.

[Class71]

Which scenario would you chose.

1.Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill tell Marquette, that if they hire Brian Wardle they will commit.   

2. Diamond Stone and Ahmad Hill say that they will not play for Shaka Smart, and instead will head to the Badgers

3. Ahmad Hill says that if you Hire Ben Howland, I am in.  D-Stone says I will play for Badgers if you hire him.   


I pick scenario 1

The coaching choice is much more important than individual players.

[madtownwarrior]

yep...

This is the dumbest thread I've read today, which is saying a lot