| Game Date | Location | Final Score | Note | 
|---|---|---|---|
| March 21, 1963 | New York, New York | L 64-70 | NIT | 
| March 14, 1967 | New York, New York | W 81-80 | Overtime, NIT | 
| December 7, 1983 | Providence, Rhode Island | L 60-64 | Overtime | 
| January 19, 1985 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 84-58 | |
| March 14, 1997 | Charlotte, North Carolina | L 59-81 | NCAA Tournament | 
| March 4, 2006 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 88-78 | |
| January 4, 2007 | Providence, Rhode Island | L 59-74 | |
| February 3, 2007 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 69-62 | |
| January 3, 2008 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 96-65 | |
| January 17, 2009 | Providence, Rhode Island | W 91-82 | Jeff Xavier's Brother Game | 
| January 17, 2010 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 93-63 | |
| February 6, 2010 | Providence, Rhode Island | W 82-79 | |
| February 27, 2011 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 86-62 | |
| March 8, 2011 | New York, New York | W 87-66 | Big East Tournament | 
| January 21, 2012 | Providence, Rhode Island | W 79-72 | |
| January 26, 2013 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 81-71 | Bat Game | 
| January 30, 2014 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 61-50 | |
| March 4, 2014 | Providence, Rhode Island | L 80-81 | Double OT | 
| January 5, 2015 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 75-60 | |
| March 1, 2015 | Providence, Rhode Island | L 66-77 | #25 Providence | 
| January 5, 2016 | Providence, Rhode Island | W 65-64 | #8 Providence | 
| February 10, 2016 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 96-91 | 2OT, #20 Providence | 
| January 28, 2017 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | L 78-79 | |
| February 25, 2017 | Providence, Rhode Island | L 69-73 | |
| January 3, 2018 | Providence, Rhode Island | W 95-90 | OT | 
| February 3, 2018 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | L 75-77 | |
| January 20, 2019 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | W 79-68 | |
| February 23, 2019 | Providence, Rhode Island |