I've changed my mind

[1SE]

I think it ultimately comes down to hubris.

Publicly Shaka seems very down to earth and humble. That said, he had the hubris to believe he could turn Hamilton into a serviceable big. The hubris to believe he could be turn right when everyone else turned left and get the same or better results.

If Shaka is able to take a humble look after this season and say "we need to trim the fat on the team" then he'll get considerably better. If he takes a look and says "the issue is our age, the core pieces were too inexperienced, a year of experience and they'll be great!" Then he'll be out of work.

As Sultan says, shaka will be coaching for his job next year and anyone thinking he's earned back to back years of this level of crap is not objective.

The hubris to deploy the NORMILTON!

[Tums Festival]

I know several will tell you Shaka has changed his tune, and maybe he has.  But did you watch the 60 second vimeo video I linked?

That video was uploaded October 28th of last year. A whole helluva lot has changed since then.

[dgies9156]

Marquette is at a crossroad -- again.

1) Continue the charade of RGV and live in the past. By March 2027, Coach Shaka either leaves and the Marquette coaching merry-go-round continues or we regress into a weak mid-major and losing to DePaul twice, Providence, Seton Hall, Butler and other teams becomes commonplace.

2) Step up, spend money, become a "Purdue" and again compete with UConn and Slick Rick. This will be expensive and a total departure from where we are, but I suspect even the best of our current team, Nigel, Royce and Adrien, would be excited about this if we brought in the "right" people who filled holes.

The need for change is urgent. Failure to act means we lose what we have, as our best players undoubtedly will entertain offers to go where they can win now. We'll be left with a hollowed-out program that is reminiscent of DePaul for the last 30 years, with no apparent way out.

Next year, we will celebrate the 50th anniversary of our 1977 Championship team. We will be reminded of how good we once were and how great we can be again. Last thing in the world anyone wants to happen as the university celebrates the 1977 accomplishment will be have a team as bad, unfocused and losing as this team is.

[jfp61]

The need for change is urgent. Failure to act means we lose what we have, as our best players undoubtedly will entertain offers to go where they can win now.

With respect to the players currently on the roster.

I don't think anyone on our roster is good enough to be Michigan or Duke's 6th man this year.

If the roster gets blown up... life would be fine.

[Scoop Snoop]

I think it ultimately comes down to hubris.

Publicly Shaka seems very down to earth and humble. That said, he had the hubris to believe he could turn Hamilton into a serviceable big. The hubris to believe he could be turn right when everyone else turned left and get the same or better results.

If Shaka is able to take a humble look after this season and say "we need to trim the fat on the team" then he'll get considerably better. If he takes a look and says "the issue is our age, the core pieces were too inexperienced, a year of experience and they'll be great!" Then he'll be out of work.

As Sultan says, shaka will be coaching for his job next year and anyone thinking he's earned back to back years of this level of crap is not objective.

Nice spot-on summary in italics. Kudos!

Even though scoop is clearly an opinion forum, the posts here are mostly presented as factual-"I'm right, which means you're wrong, and that settles it!"

My opinion is that what Shaka will do is far from predictable. I think that the statement from the Athletic Department was so forced that I do not read his openness to transfers as being something that he wholeheartedly accepts. And despite the enormous ramifications of Shaka departing from Marquette, his walking away would not be a total shock to me, although I think it is very unlikely. He seems so deeply committed to his personal beliefs and the potential consequences that he may say "Damn the torpedoes! Full speed ahead!" and go down with the ship.

The alternative-that he will finally torpedo RGV as the operating system and stop playing the role of Coach Don Quixote-is also a real possibility. If any good came out of the Gawdawful DePaul fiasco, perhaps any remaining illusions that Shaka may have had that he could make RGV 2.0 work hopefully were extinguished.