Flawed review system

[GooooMarquette]

So they can review a play to see if Jackson was behind the 3-point line...and during the review then can clearly see that he traveled, but they can't change the call to traveling.

If you get to stop the game to review a call, you should be able to call whatever you see on the replay.

[Tugg Speedman]

I agree

He moved his pivot foot twice ... two travels and no call!

[rocket surgeon]

maybe this is a good time to ask why, when a team inbounds the ball from say end court and wants to savwe time from coming off the clock, they roll the ball inbounds, don't touch it until it gets close to half court.`  fine, i get that, but if the ball goes untouched for 5 seconds, why isn't that a 5 sec violation just as when they can't inbound the ball for 5 sec?

[MU82]

maybe this is a good time to ask why, when a team inbounds the ball from say end court and wants to savwe time from coming off the clock, they roll the ball inbounds, don't touch it until it gets close to half court.`  fine, i get that, but if the ball goes untouched for 5 seconds, why isn't that a 5 sec violation just as when they can't inbound the ball for 5 sec?

The ball only has to leave the inbounder's hands 5 seconds after the ref hands it to him and begins the count. It doesn't matter how long it travels in the air or on the floor before touching the intended target.

[HutchwasClutch]

Replay in everything sucks- slows games to a crawl, still gets many calls wrong, officials are afraid what their eyes tell them, etc.  Baseball this year is going to be a joke.  They were the last sport that had it right still, review if a home run is a home run and leave everything else alone.  I despise replay. 

[MUEng92]

I am a replay proponent in general, but college baketball this year has made doubts creep in. 

The replays seem more frequent than other sports and seem to take longer.

The refs will sit and look at the monitor for 3 minutes, walk to center court and talk for 1 minute, go back to the monitor for 1 minute and watch some more, meet again at center court for 30 secs, then call in the coaches and talk to them for 30 secs before finally saying their original ruling stands but we are going to put 0.3 secs back on the clock.

[GB Warrior]

The one that drives me nuts in the college game is the flagarant foul review. I know we as a culture are big on protecting the NCAA's investment our athlete-student brains, but at some point, you have to leave this one to the eye test. Make a professional judgement whether, in real-time, it looked egregious and deserving of a T and/or ejection.