MUScoop
MUScoop => The Superbar => Topic started by: muwarrior69 on March 06, 2024, 11:14:55 AM
-
https://www.sportingnews.com/us/ncaa-basketball/news/dartmouth-mens-basketball-union-vote-explained-college-sports/9ff3fe8f1beee4868dfa8789
-
What's already been an interesting time for college athletes (and college athletics) just got even more interesting.
-
https://www.sportingnews.com/us/ncaa-basketball/news/dartmouth-mens-basketball-union-vote-explained-college-sports/9ff3fe8f1beee4868dfa8789
Good.
-
So .. being in the player's union, can you file a grievance for not getting enough playing time? Or for being made to run laps?
If you were late for practice and got suspended, would you get a union rep to litigate your case?
If you fouled out of a game, would you have rights against referees who are impeding your performance?
-
So .. being in the player's union, can you file a grievance for not getting enough playing time? Or for being made to run laps?
If you were late for practice and got suspended, would you get a union rep to litigate your case?
If you fouled out of a game, would you have rights against referees who are impeding your performance?
Pretty sure you're being facetious, but I'll throw out an answer anyway ...
As is the case with union members of pro sports leagues, rights will have been collectively bargained.
And, as is the case with the NBA and WNBA contracts, I seriously doubt things such as playing time, having to run gassers, and foul calls will have been part of a collective-bargaining agreement.
-
Pretty sure you're being facetious, but I'll throw out an answer anyway ...
As is the case with union members of pro sports leagues, rights will have been collectively bargained.
And, as is the case with the NBA and WNBA contracts, I seriously doubt things such as playing time, having to run gassers, and foul calls will have been part of a collective-bargaining agreement.
It was a joke.
But they can and will strike. It will be interesting is the players/union lawyers go after general funds and endowments for compensation.
Seems doubtful they would be successful, but the precedent in other pro sports are a % of all the entities revenues.
-
I guess the players would have to follow these rules.
https://policies.dartmouth.edu/policy/employee-educational-assistance
-
It was a joke.
But they can and will strike. It will be interesting is the players/union lawyers go after general funds and endowments for compensation.
Seems doubtful they would be successful, but the precedent in other pro sports are a % of all the entities revenues.
If they succeed at forming a union and strike, that is their right. It wouldn't bother me at all.
-
It will be interesting is the players/union lawyers go after general funds and endowments for compensation.
Seems doubtful they would be successful, but the precedent in other pro sports are a % of all the entities revenues.
Sure, but that's the result of collective bargaining and can be directly tied to the players' labor.
Good luck arguing that Dartmouth's endowment is a result of the basketball team's efforts.
-
lol. Endowments can’t be “gone after” by unions that represent other employees at colleges and universities. There are laws that govern these things you know.
-
Sure, but that's the result of collective bargaining and can be directly tied to the players' labor.
Good luck arguing that Dartmouth's endowment is a result of the basketball team's efforts.
I don't disagree. How about at Kansas or Kentucky or Arizona or Alabama?
I gotta believe the endowments are safe. As I question above, how about the general, tuition generated funds?
-
I don't disagree. How about at Kansas or Kentucky or Arizona or Alabama?
I gotta believe the endowments are safe. As I question above, how about the general, tuition generated funds?
Doesn't the phrase "tuition-generating funds" answer your question?
-
Doesn't the phrase "tuition-generating funds" answer your question?
Not really. I think a good attorney may be able to argue some portion of the tuition is generated as a result of athletics or the success of athletics. There are plenty of reports every year about how applications rise and gifts increase as a result of athletic success.
Guys, I'm not suggesting the players will milk the school dry, simply asking thoughts on how much can the players get? I know the lawyers will be asking for everything, but what would be realistic?
-
Are scholarships taxable?
There would certainly be tax implications if the athletes are deemed to be employees. Would they also be responsible for Social Security taxes, too?
-
Are scholarships taxable?
There would certainly be tax implications if the athletes are deemed to be employees. Would they also be responsible for Social Security taxes, too?
I don't think they are, nor should they be.
But, you are going to have a lot of colleges going on the record in court that they are, in fact, compensation. That will be fun to put that toothpaste back in the tube.
-
It’s Dartmouth. 🙄
Does anyone take them seriously?
-
It’s Dartmouth. 🙄
Does anyone take them seriously?
I think everyone is making the assumption that this will have spill over effect to all college sports.
If it does not, your take is correct.
-
It’s Dartmouth. 🙄
Does anyone take them seriously?
Yep, a bunch of entitled mediocre (at best) basketball players getting a free Ivy League education and contacts for future earnings. Why do they want to unionize? Better working conditions?
-
Yep, a bunch of entitled mediocre (at best) basketball players getting a free Ivy League education and contacts for future earnings. Why do they want to unionize? Better working conditions?
Just to note, Ivies don't give sports scholarships.
-
Not really. I think a good attorney may be able to argue some portion of the tuition is generated as a result of athletics or the success of athletics. There are plenty of reports every year about how applications rise and gifts increase as a result of athletic success.
Good luck with that, I guess.
Will the players then be docked pay if applications decline?
-
Just to note, Ivies don't give sports scholarships.
wink, wink- I know quite a few who have played sports at Ivies who would not have been admitted if not for their athletic ability.
-
wink, wink- I know quite a few who have played sports at Ivies who would not have been admitted if not for their athletic ability.
Sure, but being admitted and being given an athletic scholarship are not the same.
Of course, there are other forms of financial aid they can (and do) offer athletes. But technically speaking, they're not athletic scholarships.
-
wink, wink- I know quite a few who have played sports at Ivies who would not have been admitted if not for their athletic ability.
Luckily, Ivy League schools won’t exist in a few years
-
Good luck with that, I guess.
Will the players then be docked pay if applications decline?
Will the players be docked if revenues decline? I'd say yes. That's what would happen in the NFL. The salary cap is adjusted based upon revenues.
-
Will the players be docked if revenues decline? I'd say yes. That's what would happen in the NFL. The salary cap is adjusted based upon revenues.
Now there's a salary cap? One in which the institutions will include tuition as an athletic department revenue?
Methinks you're trolling us.
-
Are scholarships taxable?
There would certainly be tax implications if the athletes are deemed to be employees. Would they also be responsible for Social Security taxes, too?
Ivy League does not offer athletic scholarships. If I read the rules that Dartmouth has for employees, if the cost of courses exceeds 5K the amount over 5K would be considered taxable income.
-
Sure, but being admitted and being given an athletic scholarship are not the same.
Of course, there are other forms of financial aid they can (and do) offer athletes. But technically speaking, they're not athletic scholarships.
If it walks like a duck... Average student who can dunk a basketball gets a full "academic" or "of need" scholarship.
On a side note, I think one thing the union will push for is the ability to play as a grad student.
-
Guess that means college athletic scholarships are now taxable.
-
I do know first hand, and there have been articles written, that PE firms are raising funds to take a position in college teams. How will this affect what is going on?
I would think that this will further define them as for profit enterprises.
-
Guess that means college athletic scholarships are now taxable.
Why?
-
Why?
Right. And its hardly unprecedented. Teaching assistants and research assistants are often unionized. They can receive scholarships and a stipend free of federal income tax.