Sitting here watching St Johns playing Connecticut. There is no way our roster can compete with either one of them. Just really struck me as to how far we have fallen compared to the more elite teams in the country. We seriously are in danger of becoming a nobody. Something needs to change quickly!
Quote from: drbob on February 06, 2026, 08:13:15 PMSitting here watching St Johns playing Connecticut. There is no way our roster can compete with either one of them. Just really struck me as to how far we have fallen compared to the more elite teams in the country. We seriously are in danger of becoming a nobody. Something needs to change quickly!
You haven't shown up for quite a while, so I guess that you are unaware that your criticisms have been stated over and over and over and over here. And yes, I have often repeated myself here as have most scoopers, but a rant like this?
Take a deep breath and enjoy the SJU and UCONN game. Something is NOT going to change quickly with our team.
Most years we can absolutely compete with this St Johns team.
Quote from: drbob on February 06, 2026, 08:13:15 PMSitting here watching St Johns playing Connecticut. There is no way our roster can compete with either one of them. Just really struck me as to how far we have fallen compared to the more elite teams in the country. We seriously are in danger of becoming a nobody. Something needs to change quickly!
Relax. The calvary is coming. I see a positive offseason ahead.
Trash - You see a positive offseason?
Here's what I see:
No one else leaves. Shaka ( maybe ) adds one guy out of the portal. He otherwise runs it back. Tells everyone that the team has " improved " in 2d half of the year. And RGV BABY !
I hope I'm wrong...
Quote from: Mu8891 on February 06, 2026, 09:42:51 PMTrash - You see a positive offseason?
Here's what I see:
No one else leaves. Shaka ( maybe ) adds one guy out of the portal. He otherwise runs it back. Tells everyone that the team has " improved " in 2d half of the year. And RGV BABY !
I hope I'm wrong...
I disagree. Because if he decides to run it back, he will be looking for a new job in '27.
A lot of scoopers think 1 or 2 portal additions will right the ship! I think the deficit in talent is greater than that. We need some players with actual basketball skills who are physical and can rebound.
Quote from: MuggsyB on February 06, 2026, 09:49:41 PMI disagree. Because if he decides to run it back, he will be looking for a new job in '27.
I'd agree with this 6 weeks ago. With the improvement I've seen I'd say even he doesn't grab a transfer(he should) still we will be much better next year. Not saying good but better than a fireable season.
Quote from: drbob on February 06, 2026, 10:10:10 PMA lot of scoopers think 1 or 2 portal additions will right the ship! I think the deficit in talent is greater than that. We need some players with actual basketball skills who are physical and can rebound.
We have several young players with actual basketball skills right now, notably James, Parham and Stevens. But yes, we need lots more who can help in many areas.
Quote from: Johnny B on February 06, 2026, 10:14:06 PMI'd agree with this 6 weeks ago. With the improvement I've seen I'd say even he doesn't grab a transfer(he should) still we will be much better next year. Not saying good but better than a fireable season.
I feel the same way but I don't think being better will be enough if we're a non-factor. It's extremely unfortunate we didn't really cash in with back to back #2 seeds. We absolutely could have, and arguably should have, made deep runs both seasons. It's amazing to think how great Chase was vs Colorado.
Quote from: drbob on February 06, 2026, 10:10:10 PMA lot of scoopers think 1 or 2 portal additions will right the ship! I think the deficit in talent is greater than that. We need some players with actual basketball skills who are physical and can rebound.
Given the growth we've seen from NJ, Stevens, Royce, & Owens, adding 2 starter level players (center, wing) and a rotation guard should suffice. It'll require one of Clark or Sheek to be a serviceable piece and probably one other guy to be able to give 15-20 bench minutes, but it's pretty clear there's something there with that first group of 4.
In addition, Chase leaving will be addition by subtraction based on what he's done this year.
Good points Brew. Especially about Chase. I think once Nigel proved he was the team leader Chase tapped out
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 06, 2026, 11:00:54 PMGiven the growth we've seen from NJ, Stevens, Royce, & Owens, adding 2 starter level players (center, wing) and a rotation guard should suffice. It'll require one of Clark or Sheek to be a serviceable piece and probably one other guy to be able to give 15-20 bench minutes, but it's pretty clear there's something there with that first group of 4.
In addition, Chase leaving will be addition by subtraction based on what he's done this year.
Somethings there, but not enough.
It would definitely either take several of the incoming crop really outshining expectations, à la Nigel, or a few immediate high impact guys transferring over, or perhaps even both.
Ultimately it's likely both, as the transfers would help in the immediate future in the next season or two, while the incoming crop would help the next wave of sustained success.
All in all looks brighter than a month ago, and I agree that Nigel and maybe even Royce could be a big revelation for a bright future, with Adrien and Damarius likely/possibly being able to hold their own.
Too much "could" for my liking though, so I hope and expect coach to get in the lab and right the ship quite a bit, much like he did in his first month or two on the job
Quote from: Scoop Snoop on February 06, 2026, 08:43:42 PMYou haven't shown up for quite a while, so I guess that you are unaware that your criticisms have been stated over and over and over and over here. And yes, I have often repeated myself here as have most scoopers, but a rant like this?
Take a deep breath and enjoy the SJU and UCONN game. Something is NOT going to change quickly with our team.
Good gracious you can be a pompous ass! You took some time off this season too. More people show up around NMD and you decide to be the arbitrator of when they are allowed to breath!?
Quote from: DoctorV on February 06, 2026, 11:23:55 PMSomethings there, but not enough.
It would definitely either take several of the incoming crop really outshining expectations, à la Nigel, or a few immediate high impact guys transferring over, or perhaps even both.
Ultimately it's likely both, as the transfers would help in the immediate future in the next season or two, while the incoming crop would help the next wave of sustained success.
All in all looks brighter than a month ago, and I agree that Nigel and maybe even Royce could be a big revelation for a bright future, with Adrien and Damarius likely/possibly being able to hold their own.
Too much "could" for my liking though, so I hope and expect coach to get in the lab and right the ship quite a bit, much like he did in his first month or two on the job
Every transfer considered - and hopefully signed - should be an immediate help on Day 1. If he isn't at least 2021 Morsell level, what's the point?
You add the likes of 2021 Morsell and Kuath to the top 5 returnees (including MP and DO in the mix), and add Sheek and Egbuonu, that team can contend on Day 1.
I really believe that.
That's the frustrating part - we don't need Dybantsa and Shaq, just 2-3 good D1 players. They're out there, and they'd be happy to be part of our culture.
Right. They need 2 or 3 guys. I'd say 3 that can be in their top 7 players.
But how does it happen? They have one spot. You think SS will tell Hamilton or Tre to take a hike ? ( Or, for some of the more delicate posters ... have a nice, fatherly, supportive conversation where he suggests that the Horizon League is lovely this time of year? )
I don't see it.
And ... if they just add one guy they will probably be a bit " better "...
Cuz they will soften up the NC schedule and he will have enough sense to not play
Hamilton, Jones and Tre. But " better "
will be what .500 overall? Middle of the pack in BE ?
Quote from: Mu8891 on February 07, 2026, 08:11:21 AMRight. They need 2 or 3 guys. I'd say 3 that can be in their top 7 players.
But how does it happen? They have one spot. You think SS will tell Hamilton or Tre to take a hike ? ( Or, for some of the more delicate posters ... have a nice, fatherly, supportive conversation where he suggests that the Horizon League is lovely this time of year? )
I don't see it.
And ... if they just add one guy they will probably be a bit " better "...
Cuz they will soften up the NC schedule and he will have enough sense to not play
Hamilton, Jones and Tre. But " better "
will be what .500 overall? Middle of the pack in BE ?
I think there are three possibilities:
1) Shaka goes against RGV, creates 2-3 more scholarships on top of Zaide, reinforces with transfers, and we're competitive again.
2) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes at most one transfer, we are mediocre again and he's fired in 13 months.
3) Shaka gets out ahead of the pitchforks, parachuting to a Pitt/Wake/Rutgers type of job and we get a new coach that overhauls the roster.
Quote from: Mu8891 on February 06, 2026, 09:42:51 PMTrash - You see a positive offseason?
Here's what I see:
No one else leaves. Shaka ( maybe ) adds one guy out of the portal. He otherwise runs it back. Tells everyone that the team has " improved " in 2d half of the year. And RGV BABY !
I hope I'm wrong...
After the radio show I tend to agree with you and unless Dr. V's devastating post on how the team has regressed in scoring over the last few years is reversed it will be more of the same next season.
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 07, 2026, 08:22:53 AMI think there are three possibilities:
1) Shaka goes against RGV, creates 2-3 more scholarships on top of Zaide, reinforces with transfers, and we're competitive again.
2) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes at most one transfer, we are mediocre again and he's fired in 13 months.
3) Shaka gets out ahead of the pitchforks, parachuting to a Pitt/Wake/Rutgers type of job and we get a new coach that overhauls the roster.
Or
4) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes one transfer, and we are back in the tournament.
Quote from: rocky_warrior on February 06, 2026, 11:32:08 PMGood gracious you can be a pompous ass! You took some time off this season too. More people show up around NMD and you decide to be the arbitrator of when they are allowed to breath!?
Guilty as charged.
Quote from: IrwinFletcher on February 07, 2026, 08:37:09 AMOr
4) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes one transfer, and we are back in the tournament.
Lol
Quote from: DoctorV on February 06, 2026, 11:23:55 PMSomethings there, but not enough.
It would definitely either take several of the incoming crop really outshining expectations, à la Nigel, or a few immediate high impact guys transferring over, or perhaps even both.
Ultimately it's likely both, as the transfers would help in the immediate future in the next season or two, while the incoming crop would help the next wave of sustained success.
All in all looks brighter than a month ago, and I agree that Nigel and maybe even Royce could be a big revelation for a bright future, with Adrien and Damarius likely/possibly being able to hold their own.
Too much "could" for my liking though, so I hope and expect coach to get in the lab and right the ship quite a bit, much like he did in his first month or two on the job
Could not agree with you more, but those first months on the job were before all this NIL/ Revenue Sharing Business. May not be that easy.
Big picture, I believe Shaka hates to lose. There has been moderate improvement but not enough for him to avoid transfers. Young guys are needed as depth because it would be very risky to rely on them as starters.
No guarantees, but it would be shocking for him to stay the course and probably the end of his time at MU. He'd have no other options other than a step down to a mid-major. I just can't see him putting himself in that position.
Quote from: drbob on February 06, 2026, 08:13:15 PMSitting here watching St Johns playing Connecticut. There is no way our roster can compete with either one of them. Just really struck me as to how far we have fallen compared to the more elite teams in the country. We seriously are in danger of becoming a nobody. Something needs to change quickly!
You should tell Reeker this. For the past two years it was patently obvious that the gap between MU and those two programs was widening, And of course Reeker and a few others were highly critical and sneering and scoffing at my pointing this out. Yet, here we are, and no solutions in sight. At least no solutions except speculation that Shaka has seen the light and will adapt. I guess getting smacked across the head with a 2 by 4 to cause somebody to wake up and smell the coffee is better than not adapting, but right now there is no evidence that Shaka has finally wised up. There is talent on the roster, just not enough at this point. That is on Shaka. Hopefully he will adapt. But then again, there is the old saying, You cant teach an old dog new tricks. Next year looks like the same. Something must change and quickly.
Quote from: IrwinFletcher on February 07, 2026, 08:37:09 AMOr
4) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes one transfer, and we are back in the tournament.
Not a possibility I see. It would take more production from multiple redshirts in one season than we've seen in the first five years of Shaka's tenure.
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 07, 2026, 08:52:56 AMNot a possibility I see. It would take more production from multiple redshirts in one season than we've seen in the first five years of Shaka's tenure.
Maybe. But if we have been performing as the 66th best team in the country since Caedin's minutes have been reduced, and if losing Chase is truly addition by subtraction, and we get contributions from two of the red shirts or incoming freshman (not insane given Sheek is redshirting because he should be on high school, and him and Egbuonu are both ranked higher than NJ and Stevens who are contributing this year), plus we see even minor development from the current freshman and sophomores, then by adding one portal players that's at least a bubble level team.
Having said all that, I'm not convinced we're one of the top 66 teams even playing the right players the right minutes this year.
Quote from: WhiteTrash on February 07, 2026, 08:49:00 AMBig picture, I believe Shaka hates to lose. There has been moderate improvement but not enough for him to avoid transfers. Young guys are needed as depth because it would be very risky to rely on them as starters.
No guarantees, but it would be shocking for him to stay the course and probably the end of his time at MU. He'd have no other options other than a step down to a mid-major. I just can't see him putting himself in that position.
Trying to figure out what goes on in anyone's head is difficult, and in the case of Shaka, especially so. Marquette gave him a free reign, and he wowed us in his first seasons. He has refereed to some book that he said changed his life and meditates daily. I see him as a deep thinker and "true believer", but of
what I do not know. We all incorporate our personal beliefs into many areas of our lives, but I think a certain amount of compartmentalization is necessary.
I think he has used his free reign at Marquette to structure the team to fit many of his personal beliefs, and the possibility of having to move on, even to a mid-major, may not be enough to persuade him to change course. He just
might "stay the course", despite the consequences. The way coaching college bball has evolved and the path he has chosen are so very different in terms of roster management and financial negotiations with players and their reps. I have referred to him as Don Quixote, with his admirable but impractical ideals.
Quote from: Scoop Snoop on February 07, 2026, 09:02:37 AMTrying to figure out what goes on in anyone's head is difficult, and in the case of Shaka, especially so. Marquette gave him a free reign, and he wowed us in his first seasons. He has refereed to some book that he said changed his life and meditates daily. I see him as a deep thinker and "true believer", but of what I do not know. We all incorporate our personal beliefs into many areas of our lives, but I think a certain amount of compartmentalization is necessary.
I think he has used his free reign at Marquette to structure the team to fit many of his personal beliefs, and the possibility of having to move on, even to a mid-major, may not be enough to persuade him to change course. He just might "stay the course", despite the consequences.
I'll concede anything is possible, including next year being worse.
Based upon his history, I think the likely outcome is 2 or 3 transfers as a part of the strategy to significantly improve MU to his accustomed level of success. Also, roster upgrades may be the key to retaining our best players.
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 07, 2026, 08:22:53 AMI think there are three possibilities:
1) Shaka goes against RGV, creates 2-3 more scholarships on top of Zaide, reinforces with transfers, and we're competitive again.
2) Shaka doubles down on RGV, takes at most one transfer, we are mediocre again and he's fired in 13 months.
3) Shaka gets out ahead of the pitchforks, parachuting to a Pitt/Wake/Rutgers type of job and we get a new coach that overhauls the roster.
I see #2 being the most likely result, but the key will be the level of the transfer. If Shaka uses Zaide's scholarship to bring in an HS project, then we'll know the RVG brand is more important to Shaka and the MU leadership than winning. And President Kimo can focus on making more Facebook and TikTok videos showing how cool he is.
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 07, 2026, 08:52:56 AMNot a possibility I see. It would take more production from multiple redshirts in one season than we've seen in the first five years of Shaka's tenure.
They should push him out if he can't commit to using the portal by March. He doesn't have to use it every year but with Nigel having the potential to be one of the best PGs in the Country you can't just let an opportunity like this slow cook and hope they are good in 3 years. Go be good now or go somewhere else.
We'll add more than one transfer. Shaka talks RGV to the public, but he is also way too competitive to let another season like this happen.
I dont expect more than two additons though, maybe a third at most, but there is no need to flip the entire roster like some programs do. The freshman and sophomore classes are legit, just need a starting guard/wing and starting big to supplement them and we're back in the tournament next year.
https://x.com/CrackedSidewlks/status/2020179925785817448?s=20
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HAke70QW4AAmAt2?format=jpg&name=large)
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 11:00:28 AMhttps://x.com/CrackedSidewlks/status/2020179925785817448?s=20
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HAke70QW4AAmAt2?format=jpg&name=large)
How many schools have GMs for basketball that aren't NBA alumni (aka do nothing other than have a name recruits recognize)?
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 06, 2026, 11:00:54 PMGiven the growth we've seen from NJ, Stevens, Royce, & Owens, adding 2 starter level players (center, wing) and a rotation guard should suffice. It'll require one of Clark or Sheek to be a serviceable piece and probably one other guy to be able to give 15-20 bench minutes, but it's pretty clear there's something there with that first group of 4.
In addition, Chase leaving will be addition by subtraction based on what he's done this year.
Owens has been better but I'm not sure he's eliminated any doubts. Like last year, he shows flashes and then disappears. His stat line against Seton Hall was nothing to write home about.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 11:38:15 AMHow many schools have GMs for basketball that aren't NBA alumni (aka do nothing other than have a name recruits recognize)?
Good point - we shouldn't be ahead of the curve in roster construction because a lot of other teams don't take it seriously either.
Quote from: panda on February 07, 2026, 11:40:44 AMGood point - we shouldn't be ahead of the curve in roster construction because a lot of other teams don't take it seriously either.
No one likes a smart ass.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 11:38:15 AMHow many schools have GMs for basketball that aren't NBA alumni (aka do nothing other than have a name recruits recognize)?
Well, I'm disinclined to search the coaching staffs of 364 programs, so let's stick with the Big East.
Butler - Tony Bollier, not an NBA alumni
UConn - Tom Moore, not an NBA alumni
Creighton - NA
DePaul - Lavall Jordan, not an NBA alumni
Marquette - NA
Providence -NA
Seton Hall - Andrew Stein, not an NBA alumni
St. John's - Matt Abdelmassih*, not an NBA alumni
Villanova -Baker Dunleavy, not an NBA alumni
Xavier - NA
* Yes, I know he was fired a few weeks ago.
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 12:06:26 PMWell, I'm disinclined to search the coaching staffs of 364 programs, so let's stick with the Big East.
Butler - Tony Bollier, not an NBA alumni
UConn - Tom Moore, not an NBA alumni
Creighton - NA
DePaul - Lavall Jordan, not an NBA alumni
Marquette - NA
Providence -NA
Seton Hall - Andrew Stein, not an NBA alumni
St. John's - Matt Abdelmassih*, not an NBA alumni
Villanova -Baker Dunleavy, not an NBA alumni
Xavier - NA
* Yes, I know he was fired a few weeks ago.
So about half of one of the power 5 conferences has them. Which leads me to believe the answer is "not many." But maybe that's wrong.
Hasn't done many of the ones that have them much good, either.
There are lead recruiters in every staff. Whether they have the title of GM or not, I'm not sure a program is automatically "left behind" because they don't have a designated GM. I'm guessing some programs that are killing it have GMs while others that have GMs stink, and some schools that don't have GMs stink while others are killing it.
GM, no GM, just get the job done.
Many of us love to point out that sports is a results based business, cream rises to the top and a meritocracy. So be it!
GM BOSSMAN99??
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 12:16:49 PMSo about half of one of the power 5 conferences has them. Which leads me to believe the answer is "not many." But maybe that's wrong.
Hasn't done many of the ones that have them much good, either.
There are lead recruiters in every staff. Whether they have the title of GM or not, I'm not sure a program is automatically "left behind" because they don't have a designated GM. I'm guessing some programs that are killing it have GMs while others that have GMs stink, and some schools that don't have GMs stink while others are killing it.
I'm not really sure what the point here is. Wait until every other DI program has a GM, and then it'll be the smart thing to do?
Why wouldn't you want Marquette to explore every avenue possible and seek every edge attainable to succeed (within the rules, of course)?
Why be the last to the party?
I honestly don't understand the mentality.
Quote from: JTJ3 on February 07, 2026, 10:09:19 AMWe'll add more than one transfer. Shaka talks RGV to the public, but he is also way too competitive to let another season like this happen.
I dont expect more than two additons though, maybe a third at most, but there is no need to flip the entire roster like some programs do. The freshman and sophomore classes are legit, just need a starting guard/wing and starting big to supplement them and we're back in the tournament next year.
Agreed. This can be a tourney team next season with 2 high-quality transfers.
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 12:42:22 PMI'm not really sure what the point here is. Wait until every other DI program has a GM, and then it'll be the smart thing to do?
Why wouldn't you want Marquette to explore every avenue possible and seek every edge attainable to succeed (within the rules, of course)?
Why be the last to the party?
I honestly don't understand the mentality.
I'm not sure I have a "mentality" about it. Just pointing out the sign doesn't seem to be based in reality, at least not currently. Should we rebrand whatever person on our staff is the recruiting coordinator as "GM?" Sure.
Quote from: Vander Blue Man Group on February 07, 2026, 12:43:39 PMAgreed. This can be a tourney team next season with 2 high-quality transfers.
I agree with this.
Dismal shooting today
Ali Matta tho
Stevens, James, and Parham are the core of a good NCAA tourney team. Need at least a good big to go with them.
A big, and a knock down 3-point shooter/defender and that's a top 10 team.
Quote from: forgetful on February 07, 2026, 02:26:44 PMStevens, James, and Parham are the core of a good NCAA tourney team. Need at least a good big to go with them.
A big, and a knock down 3-point shooter/defender and that's a top 10 team.
That's getting a bit ahead of ourselves. But definitely a Tournament team.
Crean should come back and be the GM. He and Shaka have an awesome relationship. Would be cool.
I worry that convincing home wins against short-handed Creighton and Butler squads will convince Shaka RGV is working, nothing needs to change, and he'll go find Cadin/Clark 2.0 in the summer to fill Zaide's scholarship.
Quote from: forgetful on February 07, 2026, 02:26:44 PMStevens, James, and Parham are the core of a good NCAA tourney team. Need at least a good big to go with them.
A big, and a knock down 3-point shooter/defender and that's a top 10 team.
Sheek and Nash for starters. Need more.
Quote from: DienerTime34 on February 07, 2026, 02:48:46 PMCrean should come back and be the GM. He and Shaka have an awesome relationship. Would be cool.
That or AD?
Just adding a big man from the portal next year is not going to do the trick. As good as James and Stevens have been as freshmen, they are wildly inconsistent - as freshmen tend to be. One really good game followed by a so-so game. And, as good as Parham seems to be, he has yet to put a complete game together - tends to disappear in second half. So, I am not sure just adding a really solid big is enough. For instance, who is the back-up point guard? Jones? Not sure he will stay. Who spells Parham? A freshman? Unfortunately, I think the talent is way too thin and too young to think that one good portal addition will turn things around.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 07, 2026, 03:47:43 PMI worry that convincing home wins against short-handed Creighton and Butler squads will convince Shaka RGV is working, nothing needs to change, and he'll go find Cadin/Clark 2.0 in the summer to fill Zaide's scholarship.
Shakas not dumb. If he's going to the portal he's going after a proven guy imo. He ain't brining in a back up from the horizon league.
Quote from: JTJ3 on February 07, 2026, 10:09:19 AMWe'll add more than one transfer. Shaka talks RGV to the public, but he is also way too competitive to let another season like this happen.
I dont expect more than two additons though, maybe a third at most, but there is no need to flip the entire roster like some programs do. The freshman and sophomore classes are legit, just need a starting guard/wing and starting big to supplement them and we're back in the tournament next year.
The dead wood needs to go to make room. I've got three good candidates.
If you want to see a competitive team against the bottom 2/3 of the BE, we got that team.
Quote from: Johnny B on February 07, 2026, 03:59:39 PMShakas not dumb. If he's going to the portal he's going after a proven guy imo. He ain't brining in a back up from the horizon league.
That's the concern, that he won't go into the Portal.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 07, 2026, 04:09:51 PMThat's the concern, that he won't go into the Portal.
Ahh ur saying he'll grab a project high schooler not a transfer on Hamiltons level. Still though given how Clarke and ham are he'd be absolutely brain dead to do that lol.
I'm not worried that he won't use the portal, but my concern is whether he's going to open up some more scholarships. The bench scored two points today, one addition isn't going to cut it.
Quote from: forgetful on February 07, 2026, 02:26:44 PMStevens, James, and Parham are the core of a good NCAA tourney team. Need at least a good big to go with them.
A big, and a knock down 3-point shooter/defender and that's a top 10 team.
In non-conference we went 5-6 and beat no one of significance. We are 4-4 with the bottom half of the league which is not very good this year. So who have we played to make one believe we have a core of players that can compete at the level to make the NCAAT. If we beat Nova on the road and they can beat UCONN or St. John's then I'll say we have a core group of guys that can compete at that level and next season looks promising.
Looks like Shaka is content with having recruiting misses attend practice, cheer on the bench and make a turn over or two when they get in the game.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 11:38:15 AMHow many schools have GMs for basketball that aren't NBA alumni (aka do nothing other than have a name recruits recognize)?
In the Big East, the only three teams competing for NCAA bids (UConn, Nova, St John's) built their rosters with dedicated GMs that were not NBA alumni.
Quote from: Small Orange Soda on February 07, 2026, 04:26:58 PMI'm not worried that he won't use the portal, but my concern is whether he's going to open up some more scholarships. The bench scored two points today, one addition isn't going to cut it.
Shaka said post game Sean isn't able to do anything other than stationary shooting drills. Doesn't seem like he'll be back this year. Given all the injuries and his size does it make sense for him to return? Can he be productive at this level?
It should be his decision.
Quote from: Johnny B on February 07, 2026, 05:13:13 PMShaka said post game Sean isn't able to do anything other than stationary shooting drills. Doesn't seem like he'll be back this year. Given all the injuries and his size does it make sense for him to return? Can he be productive at this level?
To the former, no. To the latter, I don't care enough to find out. Hopefully his mom doesn't create a Scoop account or RIP to my mentions.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:15:14 PMIt should be his decision.
Usually I agree but I'm not sure on what planet it makes sense for all of jones tre Clark and ham to be on this roster next year. Shaka gets paid millions to win games and it's tough to have so many non contributors on the bench. The bench had 2 points today. If it weren't for NIL half of that group would be gone by now.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:15:14 PMIt should be his decision.
Imagine any other workplace where an employee incapable of doing the job gets to decide whether or not he/she gets to continue collecting a full paycheck.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 07, 2026, 04:09:51 PMThat's the concern, that he won't go into the Portal.
Worry much? Everyone needs to take a deep breath. The doom and gloom sometimes in mind numbing. No doubt in my mind there will be improvements in the offseason. Why not let it play out and then judge?
Quote from: 79Warrior on February 07, 2026, 05:37:51 PMWorry much? Everyone needs to take a deep breath. The doom and gloom sometimes in mind numbing. No doubt in my mind there will be improvements in the offseason. Why not let it play out and then judge?
How many time should we let it play out?
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 05:25:10 PMImagine any other workplace where an employee incapable of doing the job gets to decide whether or not he/she gets to continue collecting a full paycheck.
Athletes across the spectrum get to choose whether they stay, retire, how they want to go out. Not every athlete every time, certainly. But plenty.
Then there are actors, singers, politicians, greeter at Wal-mart.
Many employees keep working past when they should retire in order to boost their retirement.
So, lots of people.
Quote from: NCMUFan on February 07, 2026, 05:44:23 PMHow many time should we let it play out?
Seriously? One horrible season out of 5? Can't do anything about this season. See what happens in the off season.
Quote from: brewcity77 on February 07, 2026, 04:56:36 PMIn the Big East, the only three teams competing for NCAA bids (UConn, Nova, St John's) built their rosters with dedicated GMs that were not NBA alumni.
Those are also the two programs who have been head and shoulders the best programs and absolutely carried the conference since the New Big East was formed, and the third has head and shoulders the most money in the conference to use on its roster.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:46:48 PMAthletes across the spectrum get to choose whether they stay, retire, how they want to go out. Not every athlete every time, certainly. But plenty.
Then there are actors, singers, politicians, greeter at Wal-mart.
Many employees keep working past when they should retire in order to boost their retirement.
So, lots of people.
This is absolutely true. Anybody who thinks people don't keep their job when they're not performing well in this world are dreaming.
Quote from: Johnny B on February 07, 2026, 05:13:13 PMShaka said post game Sean isn't able to do anything other than stationary shooting drills. Doesn't seem like he'll be back this year. Given all the injuries and his size does it make sense for him to return? Can he be productive at this level?
He's going to graduate after this season, so no, let him go be a grad transfer at an Ohio-based MAC or Horizon League school.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 07, 2026, 06:16:35 PMHe's going to graduate after this season, so no, let him go be a grad transfer at an Ohio-based MAC or Horizon League school.
Chance at 2 years of eligibility, no?
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 06:08:34 PMThis is absolutely true. Anybody who thinks people don't keep their job when they're not performing well in this world are dreaming.
Your attitude seems to be, 'well other people/organizations make bad decisions, so who cares if Marquette does too'
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 06:05:57 PMThose are also the two programs who have been head and shoulders the best programs and absolutely carried the conference since the New Big East was formed, and the third has head and shoulders the most money in the conference to use on its roster.
A professional organization can act like a professional organization, or it can act like it's stuck in the past. If it does the latter the athletic director should be fired. Period.
Every pro team has a General Manager, aside from the Dallas Mavericks (interim GM), the Minnesota Vikings (currently looking to hire), & the Tampa Bay Rays (team of assistant GMs). There's no excuse for professional NCAA teams not having the same.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:46:48 PMAthletes across the spectrum get to choose whether they stay, retire, how they want to go out. Not every athlete every time, certainly. But plenty.
Then there are actors, singers, politicians, greeter at Wal-mart.
Many employees keep working past when they should retire in order to boost their retirement.
So, lots of people.
NFL GM: You know, you've spent most of the last three seasons on IR, and even when you do get on the field, you're one of the worst players in the league. We're going to have to release you.
Player: Nah, I'm staying.
GM: OK. Your call.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 06:08:34 PMThis is absolutely true. Anybody who thinks people don't keep their job when they're not performing well in this world are dreaming.
Is this something that happens at well-run, successful organizations?
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 06:31:43 PMIs this something that happens at well-run, successful organizations?
Yes? You seriously have never worked at a good organization but had coworkers who are lazy and just skate by?
I'm all for having Tre and Caedin move on. But if we're going to talk "real world" let's be real about the real world.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 07, 2026, 03:47:43 PMI worry that convincing home wins against short-handed Creighton and Butler squads will convince Shaka RGV is working, nothing needs to change, and he'll go find Cadin/Clark 2.0 in the summer to fill Zaide's scholarship.
Nice troll.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 07, 2026, 06:48:03 PMNice troll.
What exactly do you think he will do then? Because while I disagree with Billy, he's just saying Shaka will keep doing what he's doing, which you've loudly defended.
Sean not playing again this season seems likely at this point.
If that happens, what are the chances he can get another year of eligibility?
With Nigel entrenched for 30+ MPG next season, it makes all the sense in the world for Sean to move on, especially if he can get another year on top of next season.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 07, 2026, 06:36:36 PMYes? You seriously have never worked at a good organization but had coworkers who are lazy and just skate by?
I'm all for having Tre and Caedin move on. But if we're going to talk "real world" let's be real about the real world.
I've been around plenty of organizations in which some people work harder or more effectively than others, or simply are more talented.
Never been around one in which a person incapable of doing their job was nonetheless retained and compensated as if they were.
With tower's philosophy, Bob Dukiet would have coached up until his passing.
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 05:25:10 PMImagine any other workplace where an employee incapable of doing the job gets to decide whether or not he/she gets to continue collecting a full paycheck.
Dukiet lost the team, recruited poorly, had players commit assault, become academically ineligible. He was the nadir of MU basketball.
Is this what your hatred of MU has come to? Prayers up for you.
None of us Scoopers are compensated for posting here, but some here did not meet the expectations of our Moderators to be productive Scoopers and were told to move on. So even here at Scoop we cannot expect that it is only our decision to leave.
Well, if Sean turns on his teammates and engages in anti-social, juvenile behavior he absolutely should be run.
Quote from: Pakuni on February 07, 2026, 06:31:43 PMIs this something that happens at well-run, successful organizations?
When roster spots are limited and keeping said player is detrimental to the team, no, this doesn't happen.
If Sean & Caedin are on the roster next year, Shaka isn't doing this job to the best of his ability.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 08:34:33 PMDukiet lost the team, recruited poorly, had players commit assault, become academically ineligible. He was the nadir of MU basketball.
Is this what your hatred of MU has come to? Prayers up for you.
...but Marquette should not have fired him, it should have been his decision to leave, no? I don't hate Marquette, but when players are given 2-3 years and not performing it's time for them to go too, no?
I was at the game today and it was the first I noticed Hamilton not having fun this year.
Normally he's smiling, laughing, having a good time. He genuinely looked miserable out there. I don't think he's having fun in his situation anymore.
He has a big decision to make whether he wants to stay or leave.
Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on February 07, 2026, 09:09:17 PMI was at the game today and it was the first I noticed Hamilton not having fun this year.
Normally he's smiling, laughing, having a good time. He genuinely looked miserable out there. I don't think he's having fun in his situation anymore.
Quote from: PointWarrior on February 07, 2026, 09:21:17 PMHe has a big decision to make whether he wants to stay or leave.
Shaka should make that decision for him because it is painfully obvious and keeping him here to continue to struggle isn't fair for him either.
Thanks. Nicest thing anybody has said to me all night.
Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on February 07, 2026, 09:35:00 PMShaka should make that decision for him because it is painfully obvious and keeping him here to continue to struggle isn't fair for him either.
It's actually more than fair to him cause he making a hell of lot more here than he would at a swac school.
Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on February 07, 2026, 09:09:17 PMI was at the game today and it was the first I noticed Hamilton not having fun this year.
Normally he's smiling, laughing, having a good time. He genuinely looked miserable out there. I don't think he's having fun in his situation anymore.
Im sure the rev share check he gets will put the smile back on his face.
Quote from: Small Orange Soda on February 07, 2026, 07:00:07 PMWhat exactly do you think he will do then? Because while I disagree with Billy, he's just saying Shaka will keep doing what he's doing, which you've loudly defended.
You're right in that I've been a big defender of Shaka this season. Particularly against the faction of Scoopers that have suggested he should be on the hot seat and or fired if he had another down year next year. I've said there is nothing Shaka could do to course correct the team this season - so I wasn't going to throw the guy under the bus - especially with what he's accomplished at MU in his first 4 years.
I think Shaka will go after a player in the portal capable of coming in and being an immediate contributor to fill Zaide's spot. I won't be mad if he renews Tre, Sean, and Caedin's scholarships - with the caveat that whatever NIL dollars have been allocated for those players gets rolled into bringing in an impact portal player.
He can be loyal to those kids who have been high character and hard working, yet also teach the real world lessen of compensation is tied to performance. If any of Tre, Sean, or Caedin were to be upset by having their NIL substantially decreased and or eliminated and as a result transfered out - that in my view is the most honorable way to handle those kids.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:46:48 PMAthletes across the spectrum get to choose whether they stay, retire, how they want to go out. Not every athlete every time, certainly. But plenty.
Then there are actors, singers, politicians, greeter at Wal-mart.
Many employees keep working past when they should retire in order to boost their retirement.
So, lots of people.
Legends get to call their shots. Sean has played one full (mediocre) season here. It's best for both parties to move on.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 07, 2026, 09:59:01 PMYou're right in that I've been a big defender of Shaka this season. Particularly against the faction of Scoopers that have suggested he should be on the hot seat and or fired if he had another down year next year.
It's not about what anyone thinks. Shaka WILL be on the hot seat heading into next year unless he really kicks it into high gear down the stretch. If he has another year next year like this one, he will be fired.
Now, I don't think that's going to happen. He's figured out what he should have been doing from the beginning.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 07, 2026, 09:59:01 PMI've said there is nothing Shaka could do to course correct the team this season - so I wasn't going to throw the guy under the bus - especially with what he's accomplished at MU in his first 4 years.
Why are you letting him off the hook for this season?
Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on February 07, 2026, 09:09:17 PMI was at the game today and it was the first I noticed Hamilton not having fun this year.
Normally he's smiling, laughing, having a good time. He genuinely looked miserable out there. I don't think he's having fun in his situation anymore.
Getting put on a poster can be a buzzkill.
Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on February 07, 2026, 09:09:17 PMI was at the game today and it was the first I noticed Hamilton not having fun this year.
Normally he's smiling, laughing, having a good time. He genuinely looked miserable out there. I don't think he's having fun in his situation anymore.
It must've been the hook shot he air-balled 2 feet away from the hoop.
Quote from: The Sultan on February 07, 2026, 10:13:13 PMIt's not about what anyone thinks. Shaka WILL be on the hot seat heading into next year unless he really kicks it into high gear down the stretch. If he has another year next year like this one, he will be fired.
Now, I don't think that's going to happen. He's figured out what he should have been doing from the beginning.
Why are you letting him off the hook for this season?
With 15 Scholarships I can live with keeping Tre, but it is time for Sean, who should have earned his degree this coming spring, and Hamilton to move on.
Will Marquette hire a GM?
Quote from: muwarrior69 on February 08, 2026, 07:55:45 AMWith 15 Scholarships I can live with keeping Tre, but it is time for Sean, who should have earned his degree this coming spring, and Hamilton to move on.
Will Marquette hire a GM?
Broeker will be gone if they don't.
Quote from: panda on February 08, 2026, 07:09:42 AMIt must've been the hook shot he air-balled 2 feet away from the hoop.
I guess he should have shot 10001 hook shots during the summer, eh?
Quote from: The Sultan on February 07, 2026, 10:13:13 PMIt's not about what anyone thinks. Shaka WILL be on the hot seat heading into next year unless he really kicks it into high gear down the stretch. If he has another year next year like this one, he will be fired.
Now, I don't think that's going to happen. He's figured out what he should have been doing from the beginning.
Why are you letting him off the hook for this season?
I assume you forgot to apply the teal?
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 09:43:34 AMI assume you forgot to apply the teal?
Your weak non-answer is noted. Grant you it was expected...but noted nevertheless.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 09:43:34 AMI assume you forgot to apply the teal?
Tough break for Shaka last night. Seth Trimble's shot may keep him from getting the UNC job this spring. There's still hope Self could retire.
Quote from: Pakuni on February 08, 2026, 10:37:13 AMTough break for Shaka last night. Seth Trimble's shot may keep him from getting the UNC job this spring. There's still hope Self could retire.
Shows how much
you know! Few is retiring and Shaka will be announced as the new coach when Gonzaga gets KO'd in the tourney. The deal was signed over a month ago.
Quote from: Scoop Snoop on February 08, 2026, 10:44:21 AMShows how much you know! Few is retiring and Shaka will be announced as the new coach when Gonzaga gets KO'd in the tourney. The deal was signed over a month ago.
Shows how much
you know! Shaka is going to be the HC at UNC, Pitt, and Kentucky, that way he can use the Portal while still holding on to RGV as he'll just shuffle players between those programs yearly.
Quote from: Billy Hoyle on February 08, 2026, 11:33:32 AMShows how much you know! Shaka is going to be the HC at UNC, Pitt, and Kentucky, that way he can use the Portal while still holding on to RGV as he'll just shuffle players between those programs yearly.
White flag. You
got me!
Quote from: The Sultan on February 08, 2026, 09:52:15 AMYour weak non-answer is noted. Grant you it was expected...but noted nevertheless.
Your dumb original post was noted, and expected. Hey, due to one bad season, let's put Shaka on the hot seat for going NCAA 4 of our 5 years, a Big East regular season and conference championship, two Number 2 seeds, 3 NCAA tournament wins in 4 years - walking into a program that hadn't won an NCAA game in 10 years - all because he's had 1 down year (albeit with an All Big East First or Second Team, freshman PG).
You, Pakuni, Brewcity, ScoopSnoop, Billy Hoyle are some real gems - preached patience and backed Wojo for 5 years but want Shaka on the hot seat for 1 bad year. And of course Wojo didn't have to navigate good players getting $1M/ season, and managing a roster budget.
I legit like Shaka so I don't "want" him to be on the hot seat for "one bad year."
However ...
Given basketball's current climate and the speed at which programs can be rebuilt, I do believe that this catastrophic season will result in him being on the proverbial hot seat going into next season in the minds of those who actually matter.
Ners and others might think that unfair, while some believe Shaka should be fired the minute this season ends. Hell, Farley called for him to be fired after Year 1.
And here we go again with the "one bad season" BS that was in the making for 4 years. What happened to "the players are to blame" thread? Seems to have disappeared.
Trying to connect Shaka's tremendous success in previous seasons to counterbalance and absolve his "RGV errors" is disingenuous. Assuming that I (and probably others, but they can speak for themselves) am anti-Shaka is laughable. I want the original version back, (not the Kumbaya one) the one whose very impressive accomplishments you keep repeating over and over again. Thanks, but we all know about them. Your constant repetition makes you, not us, look very foolish. We are not "off the rails" like you posted in a reply to Brew, but the wild accusations in some of your many posts support my belief that they are an example of projection in your "off the rails" rant.
But I would be remiss if I did not thank you for adding my name to your list of Pakuni, Brewcity, and Billy Hoyle. I'm flattered to be included in such good company. ;D
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 02:01:44 PMYour dumb original post was noted, and expected. Hey, due to one bad season, let's put Shaka on the hot seat for going NCAA 4 of our 5 years, a Big East regular season and conference championship, two Number 2 seeds, 3 NCAA tournament wins in 4 years - walking into a program that hadn't won an NCAA game in 10 years - all because he's had 1 down year (albeit with an All Big East First or Second Team, freshman PG).
Do you know now to read? I'm not putting him on the hot seat! He is putting himself there because of this season's performance. I hope he finishes out this year strong and kicks a$$ next season. But another season like this and he might be gone. We haven't had a season this bad in a LONG time.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 02:01:44 PMYou, Pakuni, Brewcity, ScoopSnoop, Billy Hoyle are some real gems - preached patience and backed Wojo for 5 years but want Shaka on the hot seat for 1 bad year. And of course Wojo didn't have to navigate good players getting $1M/ season, and managing a roster budget.
??? I don't want Shaka on the hot seat. What makes you think I want that?
And why do you keep bringing up Wojo? Anyway, you know that NONE of Wojo's teams ranked lower on KenPom than this one right?
Anyway, my suggestion for you is to actually read what I am writing - and not what you THINK I'm writing.
Quote from: The Sultan on February 08, 2026, 02:36:45 PMAnyway, my suggestion for you is to actually read what I am writing - and not what you THINK I'm writing.
Somebody had to take over for Lenny.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 02:01:44 PMYour dumb original post was noted, and expected.
Why am I not surprised that your wittiest retort is "I know you are but what am I?"
cool, I was not aware we live in a world where Walmart greeters get the call the shots on when to call their career over. Seems like a great comparison to athletes who miss a 2 foot shot by 4 feet but still get paid 6 figures.
Quote from: tower912 on February 07, 2026, 05:46:48 PMAthletes across the spectrum get to choose whether they stay, retire, how they want to go out. Not every athlete every time, certainly. But plenty.
Then there are actors, singers, politicians, greeter at Wal-mart.
Many employees keep working past when they should retire in order to boost their retirement.
So, lots of people.
Quote from: Elonsmusk on February 08, 2026, 02:01:44 PMAnd of course Wojo didn't have to navigate good players getting $1M/ season, and managing a roster budget.
Full circle moment.
This is why Shaka needs a GM.
Quote from: Scoop Snoop on February 08, 2026, 02:34:48 PMAnd here we go again with the "one bad season" BS that was in the making for 4 years. What happened to "the players are to blame" thread? Seems to have disappeared.
Trying to connect Shaka's tremendous success in previous seasons to counterbalance and absolve his "RGV errors" is disingenuous. Assuming that I (and probably others, but they can speak for themselves) am anti-Shaka is laughable. I want the original version back, (not the Kumbaya one) the one whose very impressive accomplishments you keep repeating over and over again. Thanks, but we all know about them. Your constant repetition makes you, not us, look very foolish. We are not "off the rails" like you posted in a reply to Brew, but the wild accusations in some of your many posts support my belief that they are an example of projection in your "off the rails" rant.
But I would be remiss if I did not thank you for adding my name to your list of Pakuni, Brewcity, and Billy Hoyle. I'm flattered to be included in such good company. ;D
It's one bad year. The last 4 years have been varying levels of good to great. That's just a fact. People can't preach "it takes one offseason to rebuild in this day and age, so one down year is the leash," and then talk about how this is somehow 4 bad years.
Whether he should be on the hot seat next season probably depends on how the rest of this season and this offseason goes. And how you define "hot seat." If "hot seat" means Tourney or he's out, I don't know that I'd agree with that. If it means "another season hanging below a top 100 KP team" then sure.
Quote from: wadesworld on February 08, 2026, 07:01:07 PMIt's one bad year. The last 4 years have been varying levels of good to great. That's just a fact. People can't preach "it takes one offseason to rebuild in this day and age, so one down year is the leash," and then talk about how this is somehow 4 bad years.
I was referring specifically to the recruits starting 4 years ago who comprise this year's "one bad year". I should have been clearer. I had faith in Shaka's ability to build a solid team that would be able to take over post Kolek. Oso, Stevie and Kam. That faith vanished with what we see this year, but it started 4 years ago. Ben has had his good games, Chase looked really good until the BE games this year, but gambling on Hamilton and not going to the portal when I believe he should have acknowledged-at least to himself-that he had players who were not working out, and he needed to go to the portal. Right up until the first game, we heard happy talk.
I want to see Shaka go back to the coaching style he had that was so successful. And that requires showing the poor performers the door to make room for transfers. Leaving the decision to stay or go up to the player is, in my opinion, a huge mistake. Not saying that he will, but it could happen.
Let's hope the original version of Shaka reappears. But criticizing him for this year's team is, I believe, fair and should not be put into a Doddsian blender with his successes. There were/are two different M.O.s involved.
NM
Quoting yourself in back to back posts? Kind of dentist of you.
Damn it Tower, now I am really screwed up. And it's all your fault
Nothing but love, brother.
It seems very likely Marquette will have 2 open spots at minimum this offseason.
If Shaka brings in 2 quality starters (a center and a scoring wing or combo guard), I doubt his seat gets warm next season.
He can still make a modified version of RGV work going forward (same model Izzo and Painter use).
Quote from: Vander Blue Man Group on February 08, 2026, 08:27:09 PMIt seems very likely Marquette will have 2 open spots at minimum this offseason.
If Shaka brings in 2 quality starters (a center and a scoring wing or combo guard), I doubt his seat gets warm next season.
He can still make a modified version of RGV work going forward (same model Izzo and Painter use).
Will still need much more depth to seriously compete imo
Quote from: panda on February 08, 2026, 08:28:29 PMWill still need much more depth to seriously compete imo
How do you define "seriously compete"?
In my scenario I think that's a potential tourney team.
I just have a hard time seeing Shaka going into that portal that hard.
Quote from: Vander Blue Man Group on February 08, 2026, 08:33:26 PMHow do you define "seriously compete"?
In my scenario I think that's a potential tourney team.
I just have a hard time seeing Shaka going into that portal that hard.
Hard to define expectations without knowing who the transfers are, but regardless — I don't think a bench which would exist if we only have 2 open spots next year is anywhere remotely close to helping 5 competent players make the tournament.
Quote from: panda on February 08, 2026, 08:41:11 PMHard to define expectations without knowing who the transfers are, but regardless — I don't think a bench which would exist if we only have 2 open spots next year is anywhere remotely close to helping 5 competent players make the tournament.
Bench of Owens, Phillips, Sheek, and Egbuonu. Completely fair to say it's totally unproven. Also completely fair to say that group has a lot of potential.
Quote from: Vander Blue Man Group on February 08, 2026, 10:14:24 PMBench of Owens, Phillips, Sheek, and Egbuonu. Completely fair to say it's totally unproven. Also completely fair to say that group has a lot of potential.
[/quote
There are a few other potentially helpful pieces in Walker, Mitilic and Clark.
Quote from: Vander Blue Man Group on February 08, 2026, 08:27:09 PMIt seems very likely Marquette will have 2 open spots at minimum this offseason.
If Shaka brings in 2 quality starters (a center and a scoring wing or combo guard), I doubt his seat gets warm next season.
He can still make a modified version of RGV work going forward (same model Izzo and Painter use).
That is a tournament team assuming we keep the freshman and sophomores. No doubt in my mind. Depth will come from the freshmen and the RS freshmen. If they happen to get a third transfer all the better. But two is all that is truly needed. They will be top 3 in the Big East next year with your scenario.