For this post I can't make a poll because I havent found one I like off the top of my head. I am looking for a good fish fry in the Milwaukee Area. Parents are coming in Friday night and I have been jonesing for a good one. Here are the criteria though:
A) Beer battered deep fried fish. None of this "breaded and pan fried" crap. I want something where the crust is like a 1/5 inch thich flakey and dripping with oil. I want a place that gives full submergence to the fish. I dont want something that looks like it could be stubstituted for a filet 'o'fish from the McD's drive thru.
B) options other than fries. I like me some potato pancakes with apple sauce now and again too. I usually get both if they are options.
c) tartar sauce and cole slaw - any place that doesnt have like the premade crap would be great. Hell I don't even really want that stuff but if I didn't come from a package/container I'd probably eat it.
D) Atmosphere and beer a + but unnecessary. If there is an absolute dive that is giving me more fry than fish I'm going there.
So... is there such a place?
I am partial to Hooligans on the East Side. Many fish and side options as well as having a good beer selection. I also like Comet Cafe's too and they have a better beer selection.
Turners is always good. Can be busy if there is an event at the BC. You can get fries or potato pancakes. It hits all your criteria
Turner Hall.
The Lakefront Brewery is a worthwhile trip, but always busy during lent.
lake fronts is mass quantity crap IMO.
Comet is part of the slow food movement and actually makes damn good food.
The fish at Lakefront is not that great, I admit. But it's a really fun place to go.
Quote from: BrewCity on March 05, 2009, 11:13:43 AM
The fish at Lakefront is not that great, I admit. But it's a really fun place to go.
Lake Front is fun to drink at I will admit. They have some good beers. Wish they had a better IPA though. Pretty weak.
Robert's on Howell Avenue and Bolivar on Milwaukee's South Side...It's a small place, but their fish fry is amazing!
Sobelmans has a pretty good fish fry.
Painted Parrot, 84th and National.
Quote from: GOMU1104 on March 05, 2009, 12:47:48 PM
Sobelmans has a pretty good fish fry.
Painted Parrot, 84th and National.
I'm sorry, but if you go to Sobelman's to order anything but a Sobelman, you're a fool.
Quote from: GuyIncognito on March 05, 2009, 02:24:27 PM
I'm sorry, but if you go to Sobelman's to order anything but a Sobelman, you're a fool.
What about a double? :P
They do have a kick as BLT as well. Half a pound of bacon on it.
Quote from: Chili on March 05, 2009, 02:29:57 PM
What about a double? :P
They do have a kick as BLT as well. Half a pound of bacon on it.
Any variation of the Sobelman is acceptable. (I actually do prefer the double)
As of last night I had my 14th sobel patty 6 doubles and 2 singles since Jan 1 2009.
However given that it is a friday during lent (for catholics) I think the fish fry is acceptable. Maybe they'll make a sobel fish sandwich
Kegel's Inn on 59th and National has a good fish fry and decent sized selection of brews
Quote from: Ari Gold on March 05, 2009, 10:32:18 AM
For this post I can't make a poll because I havent found one I like off the top of my head. I am looking for a good fish fry in the Milwaukee Area. Parents are coming in Friday night and I have been jonesing for a good one. Here are the criteria though:
A) Beer battered deep fried fish. None of this "breaded and pan fried" crap. I want something where the crust is like a 1/5 inch thich flakey and dripping with oil. I want a place that gives full submergence to the fish. I dont want something that looks like it could be stubstituted for a filet 'o'fish from the McD's drive thru.
B) options other than fries. I like me some potato pancakes with apple sauce now and again too. I usually get both if they are options.
c) tartar sauce and cole slaw - any place that doesnt have like the premade crap would be great. Hell I don't even really want that stuff but if I didn't come from a package/container I'd probably eat it.
D) Atmosphere and beer a + but unnecessary. If there is an absolute dive that is giving me more fry than fish I'm going there.
So... is there such a place?
Milwaukee Ale House walleye (or cod) won't disappoint:
1) potato pancakes +applesauce
2) spicy tartar (or equivalent) sauce
3) wall eye very delicious, although sorry, not dripping with lard; cod not bad either.
4) Sauteed veggies! (Mom will approve, and it's other non-slaw/fries side)
5) Finally: Louise's demise + dozen other beers, what more could you want?
Off the top of my head:
1) Coach's bar and grill, quaint place on 13th & Layton by the airport, but standard fixins
2) Lakefront brewery is classic and has variety (bluegill, cod, tilapia, walleye, shrimp/shellfish?? i think) but be PREPARED to wait in line for a table cuz the place is usually packed. might as well go on a brewery tour if you're 21, then eat :)
Quote from: rugbydrummer on March 05, 2009, 11:26:51 PM
Milwaukee Ale House walleye (or cod) won't disappoint:
1) potato pancakes +applesauce
2) spicy tartar (or equivalent) sauce
3) wall eye very delicious, although sorry, not dripping with lard; cod not bad either.
4) Sauteed veggies! (Mom will approve, and it's other non-slaw/fries side)
5) Finally: Louise's demise + dozen other beers, what more could you want?
I am going there tonight and am now really excited. I have never been there before for Fish Fry and hearing a happy review about it is good.
Quote from: GuyIncognito on March 05, 2009, 02:24:27 PM
I'm sorry, but if you go to Sobelman's to order anything but a Sobelman, you're a fool.
Agreed. I once strayed away, slightly, from the sobelman... to the chicken sobelman. Never again, will I deviate from the true form of perfection.
I love going there with people for their first time. no need for a menu. I just want an order of cheese balls, a Sobelman burger (maybe a double) and a miller lite (substitute Bloody Mary if it is before noon).
tried the sobel. Fish fry. It was very good. They had a pasta and cole slaw. Girl scout cookies too. I'll try turners ale house next
County Clare Inn. A little pricier but fantastic. Lightly battered using Smithwicks Ale. Has good portions and great mashed potatoes or thick cut fries as a side.
Tin Fish in San Diego
http://www.milwaukeemagazine.com/currentIssue/full_feature_story.asp?newmessageid=24413
This might also be helpful :)
My intern went to Trocadero's . . . I guess it was okay :)