What jumps out to me is that its not an.immediate release of the hostages
“Alive or dead” is shocking as well.
“Here is the body of a civilian hostage that we killed, now give us 30 Palestinians who attempted to kill Israelis”.
By my math, this means Israel is holding a minimum 990 Palestinian women and children.
Maybe the reasons are completely valid, but that jumps out.
Definitely seems high, but then I thought about
A) the teen who was shot a month or two ago after stabbing a soldier at a border checkpoint
B) the Palestinian woman, who got released or pushed for release in a previous exchange, who was detained after a failed car bombing at a checkpoint.
I forget the exact number, but my BIL shared a stat of how many foiled/unsuccessful attacks there are on IDF soldiers or civilian targets near the border for every successful attack. Multiple monthly if not weekly. And that’s not factoring teenage Hamas/PIJ/etc fighters who get described as children in statistics.
There are undoubtedly some unfairly detained Palestinian civilians, as well as teens who made stupid rash decisions due to bad influence or programming by others, but I can see how the numbers get high rather quickly.