MUScoop
MUScoop => Hangin' at the Al => Topic started by: brewcity77 on February 11, 2020, 11:03:30 AM
-
For years we've heard about how Markus Howard is a poor defender, Markus Howard is a selfish chucker, and Markus Howard is a turnover machine. As we continue our #MarkusHowardNPOY campaign, Cracked Sidewalks digs into those lies to expose them for the myths they are and shows that, when comparing Howard to other NPOY candidates, they are actually a strength to his game.
http://www.crackedsidewalks.com/2020/02/dispelling-myths.html
-
Outstanding article and a great read.
I've definitely been impressed with how Markus has brought down his turnover rate as this season has gone along -- his current 14.4% is the lowest of his career. Hopefully that's a sign of him playing within the game more and the team playing together better as a whole. Now if only Koby could follow the same example...
Also, this is the first time I've ever seen an article about college basketball reference etymology. Geeky, witty, ridiculous (it takes 31 words to state what could probably be expressed in 5 or 6) and insightful all at once. Reports about the death of the English language are indeed greatly exaggerated.
The only world in which one could call Garza a "terrific" defender is one where we are going back to the original meaning of terrific, which shares etymological roots with terrible.
-
"Garza is a $**+ defender" certainly would have been easier & just as accurate, but I'm a sucker for the florid prose.
-
Very nice read and can’t hurt his NPOY chances if the voters read this.
-
I don't get the article?? Are you trying to say all the people nominated for national player of the year are gunners and turnover prone and Markus isn't any worst than them? Just mess'n with you. Nice article.
-
Very nice read and can’t hurt his NPOY chances if the voters read this.
Excellent work, Brew, and agree with the above.
Unfortunately, Markus is not likely to win even the BE POY. Check Holy Land. The east coast bias is strong, and all the "myths" continue unabated - Powell is clutch, Markus is not - Powell make the other players around him better - his teammates love Powell, they leave Howard. The overt gushing by the commentators during the SHU-Nova game (about Powell) was completely over the top. Sounded like the fix is in.
-
Excellent work, Brew, and agree with the above.
Unfortunately, Markus is not likely to win even the BE POY. Check Holy Land. The east coast bias is strong, and all the "myths" continue unabated - Powell is clutch, Markus is not - Powell make the other players around him better - his teammates love Powell, they leave Howard. The overt gushing by the commentators during the SHU-Nova game (about Powell) was completely over the top. Sounded like the fix is in.
I actually think Howard's chances of winning National Player of the Year are better than Big East Player of the Year. And it wouldn't at all surprise me if those awards ended up split at the end of the year. I think it's highly unlikely Powell wins NPOY.
-
Awesome work brew! I think even the eye test had already convinced me that Markus has improved greatly on defense. To me that really is the best summary of his greatness - many people would look at an undersized, not super quick guard, and write off any chance of his defense improving, and just tolerate below average defense since it came with incredible offense. But he took pride in improving defense as well as expanding his offensive game, and became an above average defense player. You can't ask for more in a college player. We are so lucky to have him. He really deserves npoy.
-
I hope Marquette latches on to some of this great work and distributes it directly to the media who vote on many of the awards.
-
Awesome work, Brew!
Everyone with Twitter should retweet this and let it spread.
https://twitter.com/brewcity1977/status/1227278751475605504
Also, I plan to have it teed up to respond to trolls on social media.
-
Follow up comment to those of you who follow MBB on more of a national scale than I do.
How pervasive are the myths that Brew addresses in his article? Is literally every college basketball writer aware of it, or is it magnified in our world by Badger and Big East trolls (and, I am sorry to say, more than a few posters on this board)?
-
Follow up comment to those of you who follow MBB on more of a national scale than I do.
How pervasive are the myths that Brew addresses in his article? Is literally every college basketball writer aware of it, or is it magnified in our world by Badger and Big East trolls (and, I am sorry to say, more than a few posters on this board)?
Certainly quite a few media guys have said those as reasoning for Powell over Markus plus there's a couple threads on preseason BE POY and Powell vs Howard where BE posters use those as pro powell
-
Not sure it is being discussed elsewhere on this board but Markus is about 21 points away from becoming the Beast all time leading scorer. That is a pretty big deal. He has his team in the top 20. He is doing everything right now. The Hall is a better team but I still think Markus will be the BE player of the year.
-
It doesn't hurt Powell's chances that Seton Hall is 18-5 (10-1 in the Big East). They've only lost one game since before Christmas and are ranked #10 in the AP poll.
Two seasons ago, Trae Young may have had the statistical edge over Jalen Brunson:
Trae Young
27.4 ppg, 3.9 rpg, 8.7 apg, 112.1 ORtg, 38.5 %Poss, 51.9 eFG%, 48.5 ARate, 20.0 TORate
Jalen Brunson
18.9 ppg, 3.1 rpg, 4.6 apg, 128.5 ORtg, 26.0 %Poss, 60.4 eFG%, 26.6 ARate, 12.2 TORate
But Brunson played for national champion Villanova, while Young's Sooners faded badly down the stretch -- losing 12 of its last 16 games, including first-round losses in the Big 12 and NCAA tournaments.
In the eyes of the Naismith board of selectors, team success matters.
-
Some people on Holyland not understanding the Powell comparison re assists since McKnight is the primary PG
-
Some people on Holyland not understanding the Powell comparison re assists since McKnight is the primary PG
I compared assist rates for everyone. And if Markus was just a ballhog, he wouldn't be creating as much as he does for others.
The critical stat when comparing those two is the Total PPG. Markus through scoring & assists creates 35.2 ppg, Powell creates 27.6. I'll get to value over replacement later (actually the most important part of the argument) but from an offensive perspective, Howard is far more valuable than Powell, and from a defensive perspective it's about equal.
-
Some people on Holyland not understanding the Powell comparison re assists since McKnight is the primary PG
Koby is MU's "primary" PG
-
Excellent work, Brew, and agree with the above.
Unfortunately, Markus is not likely to win even the BE POY. Check Holy Land. The east coast bias is strong, and all the "myths" continue unabated - Powell is clutch, Markus is not - Powell make the other players around him better - his teammates love Powell, they leave Howard. The overt gushing by the commentators during the SHU-Nova game (about Powell) was completely over the top. Sounded like the fix is in.
Nonsense. In the last 11 years only 2 guys from the East Coast have won - Zion and Jalen Brunson. They were both slam dunks.
And, Powell leads the team that is gonna win the BE. Seems like another slam dunk.
-
In Boston and Austin a good amount of time...General bb conversation about Marquette and Howard...
The myths
Howard is a poor defender ...comes up a lot based on his years with rowsey and no guard height. It was score on them or be outscored by them...
The no pass Markus ....it is rare for 2 good basketball players yet alone brothers to leave a “top 5 “ team, and he averages 27 points a game.. so yes sharing the ball is a concern nationally.
Turnover machine is probably less of a thing, perception is he forces in big moments reinforced by Lavin and Jackson recently.
Well done myth busters!
-
Nonsense. In the last 11 years only 2 guys from the East Coast have won - Zion and Jalen Brunson. They were both slam dunks.
And, Powell leads the team that is gonna win the BE. Seems like another slam dunk.
"Slam dunk"? Nearly every statistic, advanced and simple, favoring Markus over Powell doesn't scream slam dunk to me. I'm not saying Markus should or shouldn't be NPOY, but there's no way Powell should be. If SH was a top 3 team or having an SDSU-like run, maybe, but otherwise gimme a break.
-
I hope Marquette latches on to some of this great work and distributes it directly to the media who vote on many of the awards.
Is this a thing? I mean, do schools run organized campaigns for awards for their players the way that movie studios do for Oscars?
-
The heisman trophy in football has full scale campaigns run by the school and media..
Basketball has it on a smaller scale and also the political east coast trading of candidates
-
Better get some comparison info on Miles Powell because Seton Hall is putting the "marketing push" on him.....He was on Sports Center with Scott Van Pelt for an interview......
It was a total fluff job deal......
-
Excellent work, Brew, and agree with the above.
Unfortunately, Markus is not likely to win even the BE POY. Check Holy Land. The east coast bias is strong, and all the "myths" continue unabated - Powell is clutch, Markus is not - Powell make the other players around him better - his teammates love Powell, they leave Howard. The overt gushing by the commentators during the SHU-Nova game (about Powell) was completely over the top. Sounded like the fix is in.
Powell’s team has been running away with the conference while Markus’ team has had a slower start. That is probably driving it more than anything. If MU wins another 4-5 in a row the polling will get very interesting.
-
Better get some comparison info on Miles Powell because Seton Hall is putting the "marketing push" on him.....He was on Sports Center with Scott Van Pelt for an interview......
It was a total fluff job deal......
Get Wade to interview Markus, game over
-
Get Wade to interview Markus, game over
Actually it wouldn't be a bad idea for Marquette fans to try to get Wade, Jimmy, Jae and Wes to retweet something pushing for Markus to be NPOY
-
It’s usually run by the sports information director position in the university
-
It’s usually run by the sports information director position in the university
I hear WhoaJoe is looking for something to do.
-
I hear WhoaJoe is looking for something to do.
He be relentless.
-
Who actually votes for BE POY? Coaches? Press?
-
Alan ... as you can tell from my new signature, I really liked this article.
I have long said Howard's defense is vastly underrated. I do wish he had a little better feel for open teammates and/or court vision, but he obviously isn't a bad passer and he opens things up for teammates whenever he is on the floor. The thing that surprised me the most was the advanced stat for turnovers.
Well done, my friend. I love anytime myths get busted.
-
Better get some comparison info on Miles Powell because Seton Hall is putting the "marketing push" on him.....He was on Sports Center with Scott Van Pelt for an interview......
It was a total fluff job deal......
Lol was SVP supposed to rip into a college kid, and about what exactly?