MUScoop
MUScoop => Hangin' at the Al => Topic started by: TAMU, Knower of Ball on April 20, 2017, 04:54:53 PM
-
There seems to be differing opinions. Who does the collective scoop deem to be the best defender?
Yes the team sucked at defense.
No I will not add a "None of the above" option
-
Derrick Wilson ;)
-
As the early voting shows, there should only be two possible answers.
Extra wear 'n tear on the fingers typing in those other choices.
-
Markus Howard, because on a team with no defense, the best defense is efficient offense.
-
Either Duane and Haaniff were the least bad. Not going to say best and defense when describing that team.
-
I respectfully abstain
-
Markus Howard, because on a team with no defense, the best defense is efficient offense.
I don't see a vote in Markus' column
-
JJJ was our most effective defender, he used his length and anticipation to create steals and overall caused a lot of disruption and created runs for us.
Yes, I recognize JJJ had other defensive issues. However, he was the one guy who actually created something positive out of the defense he was skilled at.
Duane and Haanif get honorable mention both worked hard on defense so that counts for something.
-
Guess who voted Rowsey (he was lonely) 8-)
-
I don't see a vote in Markus' column
Commented, then had to go do work. Vote tallied now ;)
-
In a roster full of meh options, my vote is for 00:00
-
I respectfully abstain
Only take the easy polls, a-ina?
Or, abstaining no Matta.
Or both.
-
Markus Howard, because on a team with no defense, the best defense is efficient offense.
Reminds me of Davante's D-Rating. When the team D's up after a made basket, it's more efficient than off a turnover or live ball rebound.
-
Speaking of Davante ...
When Rowsey went to the FT line last season, did the crowd chant, "Au-to-ma-tic!"?
If not, why not? They weren't confident that the 95% FT shooter would be far more automatic than Davante was? Or they just realized that FTs no matta?
-
Speaking of Davante ...
When Rowsey went to the FT line last season, did the crowd chant, "Au-to-ma-tic!"?
If not, why not? They weren't confident that the 95% FT shooter would be far more automatic than Davante was? Or they just realized that FTs no matta?
This team didn't feast at the line like those ones did. It was probably just shock that we got there!
-
There is no Carter & Cohen choice.
-
There is no Carter & Cohen choice.
Ditto on Marotta and Franklin.
-
Who is the best defender in say the last decade or so? Starting from the Amigos' freshmen year forward.
-
There is no Carter & Cohen choice.
Ditto on Marotta and Franklin.
I anticipated these complaints. That's why there's a (min. 10 GP) in the question
-
Sam Hauser.
-
Offense was our best defense, but I'm floored that Luke is the 6th highest vote getter. Too many people buying into the MSK mentality.
Luke was slow footed, but it was the system that had him hedging screens. He was a good defensive rebounder. He was our only threat to alter or block shots.
Because we ran an up tempo, offense first style, our defense focused on steals and points in transition. That led to gambling that put more pressure on Luke and help defenders thanks to misses and blown assignments.
Luke, Haanif, and Sam should be the leading vote getters based on actual defense. Duane was also good in a reserve role, but those first three were the only guys giving us anything resembling reliable D.
-
Who is the best defender in say the last decade or so? Starting from the Amigos' freshmen year forward.
IMO
1. Jimmy Butler
2. Dominic James
-
Duane,
Sandy,
Traci...
-
IMO
1. Jimmy Butler
2. Dominic James
Gimmee Jerel over James, but this seems fair.
-
Gimmee Jerel over James, but this seems fair.
LOL 'rel got steals his first 2 years then coasted off that rep as an upperclassman
James' senior year D was the best lock-down D I've seen at MU since I've been a fan (frosh year '03)
-
Duane was a fairly good defender. He played hard with active hands, but I thought he was out of control too often (over-committing, too hands-y away from the hoop, and susceptible to little spats with the opposition that negatively impacted his overall defense).